Reconciling Failure and Success: Soviet Elites and the Collectivized Village: The Adventure of Individuality. Visual Representation of the Post-War Soviet Village and the Ambivalences of Ethnographic Photography during Late Stalinism and the “Thaw” (Englisch)

  • ISSN:
  • Aufsatz (Zeitschrift)  /  Print

The photographic inventory of the collectivized Soviet village during the Stalinist period mainly consisted of images of progress based on examples of technological modernization such as tractors and depictions of the villagers made happy by it. In the context of this "poverty of images", a photo album with pictures taken during an ethnographic expedition under the aegis of the Moscow Academy of Science to the Russian Central Black Earth Region in 1952 provides a unique insight into everyday kolkhoz life and its hardships during the lean postwar years. Of course, the Moscow Institute of Ethnography's research project was framed by the norms and values of the late Stalinist period. The ethnographers were expected to reveal obstacles to socialist progress and thereby help overcome them. Therefore, they had to study a 'typical' (yet carefully chosen) village with an ordinary kolkhoz and all its real problems. The young amateur photographer Vladimir Gorlenko's photographs of this 'typical' kolkhoz life did not correspond to the published visual norms of "socialist realism". At the same time, they did not comply with the standards of ethnographic photography as a mere means of documenting "material culture" such as clothing or housing. In the end, the research in Voronezh was dropped in favour of a more promising village in the neighbouring region of Tambov, which was presented in the famous monograph The Village of Viriatino. The article examines visual patterns in the depiction of kolkhoz life in a larger context, both within and beyond ethnographic photography and discusses the permissible visual narratives during late Stalinism and the "Thaw". It shows how Gorlenko to a certain extent stretched the framework of ethnographic photography towards social documentary photography.

Inhaltsverzeichnis – Band 65, Ausgabe 3

Zeige alle Jahrgänge und Ausgaben

Die Inhaltsverzeichnisse werden automatisch erzeugt und basieren auf den im Index des TIB-Portals verfügbaren Einzelnachweisen der enthaltenen Beiträge. Die Anzeige der Inhaltsverzeichnisse kann daher unvollständig oder lückenhaft sein.

353
Introduction: Reconciling Failure and Success: Soviet Elites and the Collectivized Village
Katja Bruisch / Nikolaus Katzer | 2017
362
Reconciling Failure and Success: Soviet Elites and the Collectivized Village: The Adventure of Individuality. Visual Representation of the Post-War Soviet Village and the Ambivalences of Ethnographic Photography during Late Stalinism and the “Thaw”
Ulrike Huhn | 2017
401
Coming to Terms With the Village: Stalin’s Death and the Reassessment of Rural-Urban Relations in the Soviet Union
Katja Bruisch / Timur Mukhamatulin | 2017
423
An Omitted Intellectual Tradition: The Chaianov School on Collective Farming
Alexander M Nikulin | 2017
445
“This is profitable for all”: Agrarian Economists and the Soviet Plan-Market Debate in the Post-Stalinist Period
Sergei Alymov | 2017
517
The State, Antisemitism, and Collaboration in the Holocaust. The Borderlands of Romania and the Soviet Union
Mariana Hausleitner | 2017